She Made Them Do It <UPDATED | 2026>

: While Pender did not physically pull the trigger—her boyfriend, Richard Hull, did—prosecutors successfully argued that she manipulated him into committing the act, hence the title "She Made Them Do It".

If you are looking for similar true-crime "deep pieces" or Lifetime dramatizations involving female masterminds, viewers often group it with: She Made Them Do It

: Facing the threat of being labeled a witch, Abigail accuses the enslaved woman Tituba , claiming she "made them do it" (referring to the girls dancing in the woods). : While Pender did not physically pull the

The film dramatizes the life of Sarah Pender , who was convicted of masterminding the of her roommates, Tricia Nordman and Andrew Cataldi, in Indianapolis. Abigail accuses the enslaved woman Tituba