(Tom Mison): A British colonial soldier who switched sides to fight for the Americans.
(John Noble): A "Sin Eater" who helps Ichabod but is later revealed to have a dark secret. Season 1 Episode Guide Your Sleepy Hollow Season 1 Recap - Lee & Low Books Sleepy Hollow - Season 1
(Katia Winter): Ichabod's wife, a witch trapped in Purgatory who provides cryptic guidance. (Tom Mison): A British colonial soldier who switched
(Nicole Beharie): A local police officer who was planning to join the FBI before becoming a "Witness". Sleepy Hollow - Season 1
(Orlando Jones): Abbie's skeptical boss who eventually aids the duo.